Docket as of April 12, 2003 11:31 pm Web PACER (v2.3) -------------------------------------------------- U.S. District Court Western District of New York (Rochester) CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 00-CV-6161 University of Roch. v. G.D. Searle & Co., et al Filed: 04/11/00 Assigned to: USDJ David G. Larimer Referred to: USMJ Jonathan W. Feldman Demand: $0,000 Nature of Suit: 830 Lead Docket: None Jurisdiction: Federal Question Dkt# in other court: None Cause: 35:271 Patent Infringement -------------------------------------------------- Case type: 1. civil 2. null UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER, a New David M. Lascell, Esq. York Education Corporation [term 06/24/02] plaintiff [COR LD NTC ret] Harter, Secrest and Emery LLP 1600 Bausch & Lomb Place Rochester, NY 14604-2711 (585)232-6500 Carol E. Heckman [term 07/11/02] [COR LD NTC ret] Harter, Secrest & Emery LLP Twelve Fountain Plaza Suite 400 Buffalo, NY 14202-2228 716-853-1616 FTS 853-1617 Gerald P. Dodson, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Eric S. Walters, Esq. [COR LD NTC] Morrison & Foersster, LLP 755 Page Mill Road Palo Alto, CA 94304-1018 (650) 813-5600 Erica D. Wilson, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Win Hwangbo, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Steven J. Koeninger, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Cynthia L. Lopez, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Marc J. Pernick, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Kanika Radhakrishnan, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Jennifer L. Piel, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Cathryn M. Sadler, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Bryan Ward, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Rachel Williams, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Morrison & Foerster, LLP 755 Page Mill Road Palo Alto, CA 94304 (650) 813-5600 Emily A. Evans, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Erik Jefrey Olson, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Morrison & Forerster, LLP 755 Page Mill Road Palo Alto, CA 94304 Harold A. Kurland, Esq. (585) 454-0717 [COR LD NTC ret] Eric J. Ward, Esq. (585) 454-0700 [COR LD NTC ret] Ward, Norris, Heller & Reidy, LLP 300 State Street Rochester, NY 14614 (585) 454-0700 FTS 423-5910 v. G.D. SEARLE & CO., INC., a Michael Wolford, Esq. Deleware Corporation [COR LD NTC ret] defendant Wolford & LeClair, LLP 600 Reynolds Arcade Building 16 East Main Street Rochester, NY 14614 (585) 325-8000 Henry J. Renk, Esq. [COR NTC ret] Nicholas M. Cannella, Esq. [COR NTC ret] Fitzpatrick, Cella, Harper & Scinto 30 Rockefeller Plaza New York, NY 10112-3801 (212) 218-2100 FTS 218-2200 Robert L. Baechtold, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Fitzpatrick, Cella, Harper & Scinto 30 Rockefeller Plaza New York, NY 10112-3801 (212) 218-2100 David T. Pritikin, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Richard F. O'Malley, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Charles W. Douglas, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Sidley Austin Brown and Wood Bank One Plaza 10 South Dearborn Street Chicago, IL 60603 (312) 853-7000 PFIZER INC., a Deleware Paul J. Yesawich, III, Esq. Corporation [COR LD NTC ret] defendant Harris Beach LLP 99 Garnsey Road Pittsford, NY 14534 716-419-8800 Gerald Sobel, Esq. [COR LD NTC] Kaye, Scholar, Fierman, Hays & Handler, LLP 425 Park Avenue New York, NY 10022-3598 Sylvia M. Becker, Esq. [COR LD NTC] Kaye, Scholar, Fierman, Hays & Handler LLP 901 Fifteenth Street, N.W. Suite 1100 Washington, DC 20005-2327 Richard G. Greco, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Kaye Scholer LLP 425 Park AVenue New York, NY 10022 MONSANTO CO., a Deleware Michael Wolford, Esq. Corporation (See above) defendant [COR LD NTC ret] Henry J. Renk, Esq. (See above) [COR NTC ret] Nicholas M. Cannella, Esq. (See above) [COR NTC ret] Robert L. Baechtold, Esq. (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] David T. Pritikin, Esq. (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] Richard F. O'Malley, Esq. (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] Charles W. Douglas, Esq. (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] PHARMACIA CORP., a Deleware Michael Wolford, Esq. Corporation (See above) defendant [COR LD NTC ret] Henry J. Renk, Esq. (See above) [COR NTC ret] Nicholas M. Cannella, Esq. (See above) [COR NTC ret] Robert L. Baechtold, Esq. (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] David T. Pritikin, Esq. (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] Richard F. O'Malley, Esq. (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] Charles W. Douglas, Esq. (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] PFIZER INC. Paul J. Yesawich, III, Esq. counter-claimant [COR LD NTC ret] Harris Beach LLP 99 Garnsey Road Pittsford, NY 14534 716-419-8800 UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER David M. Lascell, Esq. counter-defendant [term 06/24/02] [COR LD NTC ret] Harter, Secrest and Emery LLP 1600 Bausch & Lomb Place Rochester, NY 14604-2711 (585)232-6500 G.D. SEARLE & CO., INC. Michael Wolford, Esq. counter-claimant [COR LD NTC ret] Wolford & LeClair, LLP 600 Reynolds Arcade Building 16 East Main Street Rochester, NY 14614 (585) 325-8000 Henry J. Renk, Esq. [COR NTC ret] Nicholas M. Cannella, Esq. [COR NTC ret] Fitzpatrick, Cella, Harper & Scinto 30 Rockefeller Plaza New York, NY 10112-3801 (212) 218-2100 FTS 218-2200 Robert L. Baechtold, Esq. [COR LD NTC ret] Fitzpatrick, Cella, Harper & Scinto 30 Rockefeller Plaza New York, NY 10112-3801 (212) 218-2100 MONSANTO CO. Michael Wolford, Esq. counter-claimant (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] Henry J. Renk, Esq. (See above) [COR NTC ret] Nicholas M. Cannella, Esq. (See above) [COR NTC ret] Robert L. Baechtold, Esq. (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] PHARMACIA CORP. Michael Wolford, Esq. counter-claimant (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] Henry J. Renk, Esq. (See above) [COR NTC ret] Nicholas M. Cannella, Esq. (See above) [COR NTC ret] Robert L. Baechtold, Esq. (See above) [COR LD NTC ret] UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER David M. Lascell, Esq. counter-defendant [term 06/24/02] [COR LD NTC ret] Harter, Secrest and Emery LLP 1600 Bausch & Lomb Place Rochester, NY 14604-2711 (585)232-6500 -------------------------------------------------- DOCKET PROCEEDINGS -------------------------------------- DATE # DOCKET ENTRY 4/11/00 1 COMPLAINT filed; FILING FEE $ 150.00 RECEIPT # 59925 (ta) [Entry date 04/11/00] [Edit date 08/10/00] 4/11/00 -- SUMMONS(ES) issued for G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. (ta) [Entry date 04/11/00] 5/12/00 2 RETURN OF SERVICE executed as to Pharmacia Corp. 4/28/00 Answer due on 5/18/00 for Pharmacia Corp. (ta) [Entry date 05/12/00] 5/22/00 3 STIPULATION and ORDER, reset Answer deadline to 6/8/00 for Pharmacia Corp., for Monsanto Co., for Pfizer Inc., for G.D. Searle & Co. signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer . Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Paul J. Yesawich III, David M. Lascell . (ta) [Entry date 05/22/00] 6/5/00 4 AMENDED RETURN OF SERVICE executed as to G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. 4/28/00 Answer due on 5/18/00 for Pharmacia Corp., for Monsanto Co., for G.D. Searle & Co. (ta) [Entry date 06/05/00] 6/8/00 5 ANSWER to Complaint and COUNTERCLAIM by Pfizer Inc. (Atty. Paul J. Yesawich, III) against University of Roch. (bb) [Entry date 06/09/00] 6/8/00 6 ANSWER to Complaint and COUNTERCLAIM by G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. (Atty. Michael R. Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella) against University of Roch. (bb) [Entry date 06/09/00] 6/8/00 7 MOTION by Pharmacia Corp. to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff Court to set return date (bb) [Entry date 06/09/00] 6/8/00 8 MOTION by Pharmacia Corp. for Leave to File Memorandum in excess of 25 pages Court to set return date (bb) [Entry date 06/09/00] 6/8/00 9 MEMORANDUM by Pharmacia Corp. in support of [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (bb) [Entry date 06/09/00] 6/8/00 10 DECLARATION by Charles W. Wolfram on behalf of Pharmacia Corp. in support of [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (bb) [Entry date 06/09/00] 6/8/00 11 DECLARATION by John E. Dittoe on behalf of Pharmacia Corp. Re: [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (bb) [Entry date 06/09/00] 6/8/00 12 DECLARATION by Harold J. Decker on behalf of Pharmacia Corp. in support of [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (bb) [Entry date 06/09/00] 6/8/00 13 DECLARATION by Verne A. Luckow on behalf of Pharmacia Corp. in support of [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (bb) [Entry date 06/09/00] 6/9/00 14 ORDER, Response to Motion set to 7/10/00 for [8-1] motion for Leave to File Memorandum in excess of 25 pages, set to 7/10/00 for [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff, and Reply to Response to Motion set to ten business days following filing of responding papers for [8-1] motion for Leave to File Memorandum in excess of 25 pages, set to ten business days following filing of the responding papers for [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III (bb) [Entry date 06/09/00] 6/9/00 15 ORDER REFERRING CASE to USMJ William G. Bauer for all pre-trial matters excluding dispositive mattters ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III. (bb) [Entry date 06/12/00] 6/28/00 16 REPLY/RESPONSE by University of Roch. . [5-2] counter claim by Pfizer Inc. (to) [Entry date 06/29/00] 6/28/00 17 REPLY/RESPONSE by University of Roch. . [6-2] counter claim by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 06/29/00] 7/14/00 -- Tele-conference set at 11:00 7/31/00 pursuant to notice (WGB) (to) [Entry date 07/14/00] 7/17/00 18 STIPULATION and ORDER, Response to Motion set to 8/7/00 for [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer . Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III. (to) [Entry date 07/17/00] 7/25/00 -- Deadline updated; Motion Hearing set for 2:00 8/30/00 for [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff pursuant to WGB notice. (cm) [Entry date 07/25/00] 7/26/00 -- Deadline updated; In light of the motion argument sheduled for 8/30/00 at 2:00 the status conference sheduled for 7/31/00 has been adjourned pusuant to notice (WGB) (to) [Entry date 07/27/00] 7/28/00 19 DECLARATION of Susan Koniak in support of plaintiff's oppositin to defendant's motion to disqualify Morrison and Foester (to) [Entry date 07/31/00] 7/28/00 20 DECLARATION of Patricia Johnson in support of opposition to motion to disqualify Morrison and Foerster (to) [Entry date 07/31/00] 7/28/00 21 DECLARATION of Robert Blackburn Re: [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 07/31/00] 7/28/00 22 DECLARATION of Valiant C. Glickman Re: [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 07/31/00] 7/28/00 23 DECLARATION of Gerald Dodson Re: [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 07/31/00] 7/28/00 24 DECLARATION by Jeanine Arden Ornt attorney for University of Roch. Re: in support of plaintiff's opposition to defendant's motion to disqualify Morison and Forester from representing plaintiff (to) [Entry date 07/31/00] 7/28/00 25 DECLARATION by Erica Wilson attorney for University of Roch. in opposition to [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 07/31/00] 7/28/00 26 DECLARATION by Thomas E. Ciotti partner of the Law Firm Morrison and Foerster attorney for University of Roch. Re: in opposition to [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 07/31/00] 7/28/00 27 DECLARATION by Eric Walters attorney for University of Roch. in opposition to [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 07/31/00] 7/28/00 28 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [27-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [26-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [25-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [24-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [23-1] affirmation, [22-1] affirmation, [21-1] affirmation, [20-1] affirmation, [19-1] affirmation upon defendants counsel (to) [Entry date 07/31/00] 8/2/00 29 RESPONSE by University of Roch. in opposition to [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 08/02/00] 8/2/00 30 ORDER, granting plaintiff leave to file a brief in opposition to motion by def. Pharmacia that exceeds 25 pages ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 08/02/00] 8/2/00 31 MOTION by University of Roch. to Seal Declaration in support of of plaintiffs opposition to defendant Phrmacia motion (to) [Entry date 08/02/00] 8/2/00 32 ORDER granting [31-1] motion to Seal Declaration in support of of plaintiffs opposition to defendant Phrmacia motion ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 08/02/00] 8/2/00 33 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (re: decl.) (to) [Entry date 08/02/00] 8/2/00 34 MOTION by University of Roch. for Gerald Dodson, Esq. and Eric Walters, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice (to) [Entry date 08/03/00] 8/4/00 35 ORDER granting [34-1] motion for Gerald Dodson, Esq. and Eric Walters, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 08/07/00] 8/7/00 39 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [38-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [37-1] support memorandum by University of Roch., [36-1] motion to Quash def. Pharmacia Corporation's subpoena to Morrison & Foerster by University of Roch., [36-2] motion for Protective Order by University of Roch. upon defense attrneys' (to) [Entry date 08/08/00] 8/8/00 36 MOTION by University of Roch. to Quash def. Pharmacia Corporation's subpoena to Morrison & Foerster, and for Protective Order (to) [Entry date 08/08/00] 8/8/00 37 MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in support of [36-1] motion to Quash def. Pharmacia Corporation's subpoena to Morrison & Foerster by University of Roch., [36-2] motion for Protective Order by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 08/08/00] 8/8/00 38 DECLARATION by Gerald Dodson attorney for University of Roch. in support [36-1] motion to Quash def. Pharmacia Corporation's subpoena to Morrison & Foerster by University of Roch., [36-2] motion for Protective Order by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 08/08/00] [Edit date 08/08/00] 8/8/00 -- Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 08/10/00] 8/8/00 -- Minute entry: [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 08/10/00] [Edit date 08/10/00] 8/16/00 40 MOTION by University of Roch. for Erica Wilson to Appear Pro Hac Vice (to) [Entry date 08/16/00] 8/17/00 41 ORDER granting [40-1] motion for Erica Wilson to Appear Pro Hac Vice for plaintiff U of R; fee paid ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 08/18/00] 8/24/00 42 MOTION by Pharmacia Corp. for Leave to File An overlength reply memorandum (to) [Entry date 08/24/00] 8/24/00 43 REPLY MEMORANDUM by Pharmacia Corp. in support of [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 08/24/00] 8/24/00 44 REPLY DECLARATION by Charles Wolfram, Pharmacia Corp. . [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 08/24/00] 8/24/00 45 REPLY DECLARATION by Harold Decker Pharmacia Corp. in support of [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 08/24/00] 8/24/00 46 REPLY DECLARATION by John Dittoe; Pharmacia Corp. . [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 08/24/00] 8/24/00 47 DECLARATION by Roger Williams, Asst. General Counsel for Pharmacia Corp. in support [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 08/24/00] 8/24/00 48 REPLY DECLARATION by Verne Luckow, Pharmacia Corp. in support of [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 08/24/00] 8/24/00 -- Exhibits received in support of defendant Pharmacia's motion to disqualify Morrison & Foerster. (to) [Entry date 08/24/00] 8/25/00 49 ORDER granting [42-1] motion for Leave to File An overlength reply memorandum ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 08/28/00] 8/30/00 -- Minute entry: Motion argument held on Pharmacia Corp.'s Motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster - document #7. Court reserves decision.(WGB) (to) [Entry date 09/14/00] 9/22/00 50 TRANSCRIPT of proceedings before USMJ William G. Bauer, pages 1-44, 8/30/00 (to) [Entry date 09/25/00] 10/24/00 51 STIPULATION and ORDER granting [36-2] motion for Protective Order signed by USMJ William G. Bauer . Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman . (to) [Entry date 10/25/00] 10/25/00 52 MOTION by G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. for Charles Duglas, David Pritikin and Richard O'Malley to Appear Pro Hac Vice (to) [Entry date 10/26/00] 10/25/00 53 AFFIDAVIT by Charles Douglas Re: [52-1] motion for Charles Duglas, David Pritikin and Richard O'Malley to Appear Pro Hac Vice by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 10/26/00] 10/25/00 54 AFFIDAVIT by David Pritikin Re: [52-1] motion for Charles Duglas, David Pritikin and Richard O'Malley to Appear Pro Hac Vice by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 10/26/00] 10/25/00 55 AFFIDAVIT by Richard O'Malley Re: [52-1] motion for Charles Duglas, David Pritikin and Richard O'Malley to Appear Pro Hac Vice by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 10/26/00] [Edit date 10/26/00] 10/31/00 56 ORDER granting [52-1] motion for Charles Duglas, David Pritikin and Richard O'Malley to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 10/31/00] 11/1/00 57 STIPULATION re service of papers (to) [Entry date 11/01/00] 11/30/00 58 ORDER,for Sylvia Becker, Gerald Sobel and Daniel Reisner to Appear Pro Hac Vice for defendant Pfizer, Inc. ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 12/01/00] 12/11/00 59 ORDER mooting [36-1] motion to Quash def. Pharmacia Corporation's subpoena to Morrison & Foerster, denying [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 12/11/00] 12/29/00 -- Rule 16 Scheduling conference set on 4:30 1/10/01 (WGB) (to) [Entry date 01/03/01] 1/8/01 60 RESPONSE/STATEMENT by University of Roch. to [0-0] Scheduling conference (to) [Entry date 01/09/01] 1/10/01 -- Scheduling conference held before WGB (pursuant to #61) (cm) [Entry date 01/11/01] 1/11/01 61 Minute entry: (cm) [Entry date 01/11/01] 1/29/01 62 REPLY DECLARATION OF Verne Luckow in support of defendants [7-1] motion to Disqualify Morrison & Foerster from representing plaintiff by Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 01/30/01] 1/31/01 63 ORDER, set Scheduling Conference for 2:00 2/2/01 all counsel will participate by calling the Sprint Teleconferencing service ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 01/31/01] 2/2/01 64 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 02/08/01] 3/15/01 65 ORDER, set Status Conference for 3:00 3/16/01 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 03/16/01] 3/16/01 66 Tele-conference held (WGB) (to) [Entry date 04/03/01] 4/30/01 67 MOTION by University of Roch. for Emily Evans and Erik Olson to Appear Pro Hac Vice (to) [Entry date 05/01/01] 4/30/01 68 DECLARATION by David Lascell attorney for University of Roch. Re: retained as local counsel for plaintiff (to) [Entry date 05/01/01] 4/30/01 69 DECLARATION by Emily Evans attorney for University of Roch. Re: [67-1] motion for Emily Evans and Erik Olson to Appear Pro Hac Vice by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 05/01/01] 4/30/01 70 DECLARATION by Erik Olson attorney for University of Roch. Re: [67-1] motion for Emily Evans and Erik Olson to Appear Pro Hac Vice by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 05/01/01] 5/1/01 71 ORDER granting [67-1] motion for Emily Evans and Erik Olson to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 05/02/01] 5/1/01 -- PRO HAC VICE fee paid. (to) [Entry date 05/02/01] 5/4/01 -- Telephone Status conference reset at 2:00 5/9/01 pursuant to notice (WGB) (to) [Entry date 05/14/01] 5/9/01 72 Telephone Status conference held (WGB) (to) [Entry date 05/14/01] 5/25/01 73 MOTION by Pfizer Inc. for Richard Greco to Appear Pro Hac Vice (to) [Entry date 05/25/01] 5/25/01 74 ORDER granting [73-1] motion for Richard Greco to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 05/25/01] 5/25/01 75 ORDER, set Settlement Conference for 8:30 5/30/01; written submissions will be accepted up until 5:00 on 5/25/01 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 05/25/01] 5/30/01 76 Settlement conference held (WGB) (to) [Entry date 06/04/01] 6/4/01 77 MOTION by University of Roch. for Temporary Restraining Order, and to Show Cause court to set return date (to) [Entry date 06/04/01] 6/4/01 78 MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in support of [77-1] motion for Temporary Restraining Order by University of Roch., [77-2] motion to Show Cause by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/04/01] 6/4/01 79 DECLARATION by Emily Evans attorney for University of Roch. Re: [77-1] motion for Temporary Restraining Order by University of Roch., [77-2] motion to Show Cause by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/04/01] 6/5/01 82 MEMORANDUM by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Pharmacia Corp. in opposition to plailntiff's motion for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction of a state court proceeding (jl) [Entry date 06/29/01] 6/5/01 83 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Pharmacia Corp. [82-1] opposition memorandum by Pharmacia Corp., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (jl) [Entry date 06/29/01] 6/6/01 81 Minute entry: Telephone Conference; denying [77-1] motion for Temporary Restraining Order, denying [77-2] motion to Show Cause; court directs defendant's to submit an order reflecting the outcome of the conference call in one week (DGL) (to) [Entry date 06/12/01] 6/7/01 80 DECLARATION by Richard Seltzer attorney for Pfizer Inc. Re: [77-1] motion for Temporary Restraining Order by University of Roch., [77-2] motion to Show Cause by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/07/01] 6/29/01 84 AFFIDAVIT by Paul J. Yesawich for Pfizer Inc. Re: admission pro hac vice of Sylvia Becker, Gerald Sobel and Daniel Reisner. (order granting admission is doc #58) (jl) [Entry date 06/29/01] 7/5/01 85 ORDER denying [77-1] motion for Temporary Restraining Order, denying [77-2] motion to Show Cause ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 07/05/01] 7/19/01 86 TRANSCRIPT of proceedings before USDJ David G. Larimer, 6/6/01 teleconference re: TRO, pages 1-32 (to) [Entry date 07/20/01] 8/8/01 87 SEALED MOTION by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. (to compel) (to) [Entry date 08/08/01] 8/8/01 88 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (memsup #87) (to) [Entry date 08/08/01] 8/8/01 89 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in supp. #87) (to) [Entry date 08/08/01] 8/8/01 90 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. supp. #87) (to) [Entry date 08/08/01] 8/8/01 91 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. [90-1] document(s), [89-1] document(s), [88-1] document(s), [87-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. upon Eric Walters, Esq. (to) [Entry date 08/08/01] 8/20/01 92 ORDER, Response to Motion set to 9/4/01 for [87-1] motion SEALED MOTION, and Reply to Response to Motion set to 9/14/01 for [87-1] motion SEALED MOTION ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 08/21/01] 8/31/01 93 MOTION by University of Roch. to Compel Defendant Pfizer Inc., to produce docuements Court to set return date (bb) [Entry date 08/31/01] 8/31/01 94 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (memsupmcomp.) (bb) [Entry date 08/31/01] 8/31/01 95 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (declsupmcomp.) (bb) [Entry date 08/31/01] 9/4/01 96 CROSS MOTION by University of Roch. to Compel court to set return date (to) [Entry date 09/05/01] 9/4/01 97 MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in opposition to [87-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co., and in support of [96-1] cross motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 09/05/01] 9/4/01 98 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (declaration in opp. to def.'s motion and in supp. of pl's motion) (to) [Entry date 09/05/01] 9/6/01 99 MOTION by University of Roch. to Compel defendant G.D. Searle & Co. to produce court to set return date (to) [Entry date 09/07/01] 9/6/01 100 MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in support of [99-1] motion to Compel defendant G.D. Searle & Co. to produce by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 09/07/01] 9/6/01 101 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in supp. of #99) (to) [Entry date 09/07/01] 9/10/01 102 EXPEDITED MOTION by University of Roch. to Compel defendants GD Searle, Monsanto and Pharmacia to produce witnesses for deposition court to set return date (to) [Entry date 09/11/01] 9/10/01 103 DECLARATION by Eric Walters attorney for University of Roch. in support of [102-1] motion to Compel defendants GD Searle, Monsanto and Pharmacia to produce witnesses for deposition by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 09/11/01] 9/10/01 104 MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in support of [102-1] motion to Compel defendants GD Searle, Monsanto and Pharmacia to produce witnesses for deposition by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 09/11/01] 9/14/01 105 STIPULATION and ORDER, extending time Reply to Response to Motion set to 9/19/01 for [102-1] motion to Compel defendants GD Searle, Monsanto and Pharmacia to produce witnesses for deposition signed by USMJ William G. Bauer . Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman . (to) [Entry date 09/17/01] 9/19/01 106 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (def.'s reply mem.) (to) [Entry date 09/21/01] 9/19/01 107 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl.) (to) [Entry date 09/21/01] 9/19/01 108 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. [107-1] document(s), [106-1] document(s) upon Eric Walters and David Lascell (to) [Entry date 09/21/01] 10/10/01 109 MOTION by University of Roch. to Compel court to set return date (to) [Entry date 10/11/01] 10/10/01 110 MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in support of [109-1] motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 10/11/01] 10/10/01 111 DECLARATION by Emily Evans attorney for University of Roch. Re: [109-1] motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 10/11/01] 10/17/01 112 ORDER, and Response to Motion set to 10/30/01 for [99-1] motion to Compel defendant G.D. Searle & Co. to produce, and Reply to Response to Motion set to 11/9/01 for [99-1] motion to Compel defendant G.D. Searle & Co. to produce ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 10/19/01] 10/17/01 113 ORDER, Response to Motion set to 10/30/01 for [102-1] motion to Compel defendants GD Searle, Monsanto and Pharmacia to produce witnesses for deposition, and Reply to Response to Motion set to 11/9/01 for [102-1] motion to Compel defendants GD Searle, Monsanto and Pharmacia to produce witnesses for deposition ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 10/19/01] 10/17/01 114 ORDER, Response to Motion set to 10/3/01 for [93-1] motion to Compel Defendant Pfizer Inc., to produce docuements, and Reply to Response to Motion set to 11/9/01 for [93-1] motion to Compel Defendant Pfizer Inc., to produce docuements ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 10/19/01] 10/17/01 115 ORDER, Response to Motion set to 10/30/01 for [96-1] cross motion to Compel, and Reply to Response to Motion set to 11/9/01 for [96-1] cross motion to Compel ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 10/19/01] 10/17/01 116 ORDER, Response to Motion set to 10/30/01 for [109-1] motion to Compel, and Reply to Response to Motion set to 11/9/01 for [109-1] motion to Compel ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 10/19/01] 10/23/01 117 AMENDED MOTION SCHEDULING ORDER, Response to Motion set to 10/30/01 for [93-1] motion to Compel Defendant Pfizer Inc., to produce docuements, Reply to Response to Motion set to 11/9/01 for [93-1] motion to Compel Defendant Pfizer Inc., to produce docuements ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 10/24/01] 10/29/01 118 STIPULATION and ORDER, and Response due 11/6/01, and Reply to Response to Motion signed by USMJ William G. Bauer . Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman . (to) [Entry date 10/29/01] 11/6/01 119 RESPONSE by Pfizer Inc. in opposition to [109-1] motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/07/01] 11/6/01 120 DECLARATION by Pfizer Inc. in support of [119-1] opposition response by Pfizer Inc. (to) [Entry date 11/07/01] 11/6/01 121 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of pfizer's opp.) (to) [Entry date 11/07/01] 11/6/01 122 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Pfizer Inc. [121-1] document(s), [120-1] affirmation by Pfizer Inc., [119-1] opposition response by Pfizer Inc. upon plaintiff U of R (to) [Entry date 11/07/01] 11/6/01 123 Letter ORDER, Response to Motion set to 11/7/01 for [96-1] cross motion to Compel ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 11/07/01] 11/6/01 124 RESPONSE by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in opposition to [109-1] motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/07/01] 11/6/01 -- Received Declaration of Colleen Tracey, Esq. in sup. of defendants' resp. in opp. (to) [Entry date 11/07/01] 11/6/01 125 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (mem. opp. by def. to m. to compel) also received were 3 declarations (to) [Entry date 11/07/01] 11/7/01 126 MEMORANDUM by Pfizer Inc. in opposition to [96-1] cross motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/08/01] 11/7/01 127 DECLARATION by Daniel Boglioli in support of Pfizer Inc. Re: [126-1] opposition memorandum by Pfizer Inc. (to) [Entry date 11/08/01] 11/7/01 128 MEMORANDUM by G.D. Searle & Co. in opposition to [96-1] cross motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/08/01] 11/7/01 129 DECLARATION by Carrie Cottor, Esq. attorney for G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in support of [128-1] opposition memorandum by G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 11/08/01] 11/7/01 -- Received Declaration of Laura Reynolds (to) [Entry date 11/08/01] 11/7/01 130 DECLARATION by Colleen Tracy, Esq. attorney for G.D. Searle & Co. in support of [128-1] opposition memorandum by G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 11/08/01] 11/7/01 131 DECLARATION by Colleen Tracy attorney for G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. Re: [128-1] opposition memorandum by G.D. Searle & Co., in support [124-1] opposition response by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 11/08/01] 11/9/01 132 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of def. mem. in opp.) (to) [Entry date 11/09/01] 11/9/01 133 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in supp. of def.'s mem. opp.) (to) [Entry date 11/09/01] 11/14/01 134 STIPULATION and ORDER, to remove the confidential designation of defendants' moving papers filed on 8/8/01 under seal (def.s' notice of motion, memorandum in support and supporting affidavits) signed by USMJ William G. Bauer . Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman . (to) [Entry date 11/15/01] 11/15/01 135 DECLARATION by Laura Reynolds for G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. Re: [128-1] opposition memorandum by G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 11/15/01] 11/16/01 136 REPLY MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in support of [109-1] motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 137 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION by Emily Evans University of Roch. in support of [109-1] motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 138 Authorities Cited in Plaintiff U of R reply memo in support of motion to compel (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 139 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [138-1] remark, [137-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [136-1] support memorandum by University of Roch. upon all defendants (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 140 REPLY MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in support of [96-1] cross motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 141 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION by Erica Wilson, counsel for University of Roch. Re: [96-1] cross motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 142 Authorities cited in plaintiff U of R's reply memo in further support of ti cross motion to compel (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 143 OBJECTION by University of Roch. to evidence submitted in opposition to motion to comple defendant Pfizer inc. to produce documents (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 144 DECLARATION by Stuart Hanley for University of Roch. Re: [99-1] motion to Compel defendant G.D. Searle & Co. to produce by University of Roch., [93-1] motion to Compel Defendant Pfizer Inc., to produce docuements by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 145 Authorities cited in plaintiff U of R's reply memo in support of its motion to compel def. Pfizer to produce (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 146 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault(rply. of pl. m. to comp.) (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 147 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (rply. decl. in sup. of pl. m. to comp.) (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 148 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [147-1] document(s), [146-1] document(s), [145-1] remark, [144-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [143-1] objection by University of Roch. upon defendants (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 149 REPLY/RESPONSE by University of Roch. in support of [99-1] motion to Compel defendant G.D. Searle & Co. to produce by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 150 Authorities cited in reply in support of plaintiff U of R's motion to compel def. GD Searle to produce (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 151 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (rply. decl. in sup. of m. to comp.) (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 -- Received decl. of Stuart Hanely in support of plaintiff U of R's motion to compel def. Pfizer and G.D. Searle to produce (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 11/16/01 152 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [0-0] remark, [151-1] document(s), [150-1] remark, [149-1] response reply by University of Roch. upon defendants (to) [Entry date 11/19/01] 1/15/02 153 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 01/17/02] [Edit date 01/17/02] 1/31/02 154 MOTION by University of Roch. to Compel court to set return date (to) [Entry date 02/01/02] 1/31/02 155 Authorities cited in support of plaintiff's motion to compel (to) [Entry date 02/01/02] 1/31/02 156 MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in support of [154-1] motion to Compel by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 02/01/02] 1/31/02 157 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl of E. Olson in sup. of m to compel (#154) (to) [Entry date 02/01/02] 2/22/02 158 ORDER, Response to Motion set to 3/4/02 for [154-1] motion to Compel, and Reply to Response to Motion set to 3/15/02 for [154-1] motion to Compel ( signed by Chief USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 02/25/02] 3/4/02 159 ORDER, that the University's letter request (dated 1/14/02) is granted in part; defendant shall make Dr. Karen Seibert available for deposition by the University on 1/17 and 18, 2002; that the University of Rochester may make an application to the court for an order ordering the further deposition of Dr. Seibert as to any new issues raised by the New Seibert Documents or any subsequently produced documents ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 03/06/02] 3/6/02 160 MEMORANDUM by G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in support of [124-1] opposition response by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 03/07/02] 3/6/02 161 DECLARATION by Colleen Tracy, Esq. attorney for G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. Re: [160-1] support memorandum by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 03/07/02] 3/6/02 162 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. [161-1] affirmation by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., G.D. Searle & Co., [160-1] support memorandum by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., G.D. Searle & Co. upon Eric Olson and David Lascell (to) [Entry date 03/07/02] 3/11/02 163 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (plaintiff's letter brief dated 3/8/02) (to) [Entry date 03/12/02] 3/19/02 164 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of pl. reply) (to) [Entry date 03/20/02] 3/19/02 165 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (pl. reply to def. opp.) (to) [Entry date 03/20/02] 3/28/02 166 ORDER granting in part, denying in part [109-1] motion to Compel, granting in part, denying in part [99-1] motion to Compel defendant G.D. Searle & Co. to produce, granting in part, denying in part [93-1] motion to Compel Defendant Pfizer Inc., to produce docuements; granting [96-1] , cross motion to compel; granting [87-1] motion SEALED MOTION, parties are ordered to meet and confer with 10 days after the entry of this order, and set Status Conference for 2:00 5/6/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 03/28/02] [Edit date 03/28/02] 4/25/02 167 MOTION by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. to Compel the production of the invention disclosure underlying the patent in suit and certain testimony withheld based on improper assertions of privilege court to set return date (to) [Entry date 04/26/02] 4/25/02 168 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. by def.'s in sup of motion to compel) (to) [Entry date 04/26/02] 4/25/02 169 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (mem. in sup. of def.'s motion to compel) (to) [Entry date 04/26/02] 5/3/02 170 SEALED MOTION sumjgm. by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 05/06/02] 5/3/02 171 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (memsup. of def. motion) (to) [Entry date 05/06/02] 5/3/02 172 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of def. motion #170) (to) [Entry date 05/06/02] 5/3/02 173 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (stfact. re: motion #170) (to) [Entry date 05/06/02] 5/3/02 174 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (letter statement re: 5/6/02 scheduling conference) (to) [Entry date 05/06/02] 5/3/02 175 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (letter by def. Pfizer re: 5/6/02 scheduling conference) (to) [Entry date 05/06/02] 5/6/02 176 SEALED MOTION by non party (to) [Entry date 05/06/02] 5/6/02 177 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (mem. sup of #176) (to) [Entry date 05/06/02] 5/6/02 178 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of #176) (to) [Entry date 05/06/02] 5/6/02 179 Status conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 05/09/02] 5/17/02 180 ORDER, set Status Conference for 2:00 5/20/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 05/17/02] 5/17/02 181 LETTER by the U of R requesting that the court schedule the University's motion challenging the Amended Pleadings to be heard with the motion for summary judgment (to) [Entry date 05/20/02] 5/20/02 182 MOTION by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. for Leave to File Corrected Amended Answers and counterclaims (to) [Entry date 05/20/02] 5/20/02 183 MEMORANDUM by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in support of [182-1] motion for Leave to File Corrected Amended Answers and counterclaims by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 05/20/02] 5/20/02 184 DECLARATION by Henry Renk attorney for G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. Re: [182-1] motion for Leave to File Corrected Amended Answers and counterclaims by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 05/20/02] 5/20/02 185 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 05/22/02] 5/30/02 186 ORDER, set Status Conference for 2:00 6/3/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 05/31/02] 6/3/02 187 RESPONSE by University of Roch. in opposition to [167-1] motion to Compel the production of the invention disclosure underlying the patent in suit and certain testimony withheld based on improper assertions of privilege by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 06/03/02] 6/3/02 188 DECLARATION by Erica Wilson attorney for University of Roch. Re: [167-1] motion to Compel the production of the invention disclosure underlying the patent in suit and certain testimony withheld based on improper assertions of privilege by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 06/03/02] 6/3/02 189 DECLARATION by Jane Youngers, director of the Office of Research and Project Administration at the University of Roch. in opposition to [167-1] motion to Compel the production of the invention disclosure underlying the patent in suit and certain testimony withheld based on improper assertions of privilege by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 06/03/02] 6/3/02 190 DECLARATION by Donald Young for University of Roch. in opposition to [167-1] motion to Compel the production of the invention disclosure the patent in suit and certain testimony withheld based on improper assertions of privilege by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 06/03/02] 6/3/02 191 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 06/04/02] 6/7/02 192 NOTICE of attorney appearance for University of Roch. by Harold A. Kurland, Eric J. Ward (to) [Entry date 06/07/02] 6/7/02 193 Letter ORDER, granting Pfizer permission for file a reply brief that exceeds ten pages ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 06/10/02] 6/10/02 194 SECOND DECLARATION by Daniel Reisner Pfizer Inc. in support of [167-1] motion to Compel the production of the invention disclosure underlying the in suit and certain testimony withheld based on improper assertions of privilege by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 06/11/02] 6/10/02 206 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (pl.'s rply memo in sup. of their motion to comp.) (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/13/02 195 Letter ORDER, granting University's request to exceed the page limit (up to 35 pages long) for their brief in opposition to the pending summary judgment motion, and granting leave to serve brief ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 06/13/02] 6/13/02 218 MOTION by University of Roch. for David Lascell to Withdraw as Attorney (to) [Entry date 06/24/02] 6/13/02 219 AFFIRMATION by David Lascell attorney for University of Roch. Re: [218-1] motion for David Lascell to Withdraw as Attorney by University of (to) [Entry date 06/24/02] 6/13/02 220 AFFIDAVIT by Jay Stein, VP for Health Fairs for the University of Roch. Re: [218-1] motion for David Lascell to Withdraw as Attorney by University of (to) [Entry date 06/24/02] 6/14/02 196 MOTION by University of Roch. for Summary Judgment of Infringement court to set return date (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 197 SEPERATE STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED FACTS by University of Roch. [196-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Infringement by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 198 DECLARATION by Erica Wilson, attorney for University of Roch. Re: [196-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Infringement by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 199 Appendix of non published authorities in support of pl.'s U of R motion for summary judgment of infringement (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 200 MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in support of [196-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Infringement by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 201 COPY OF DECLARATION (Copy filed in error, original doc. # 211) by Edward Dennis, Professor at the University of California for University of Roch. Re: [196-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Infringement by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] [Edit date 10/24/02] 6/14/02 202 COPY OF DECLARATION (Copy filed in error, Original document #212) by Dr. John McGiff, Professor at NY Medical College for University of Roch. Re: [196-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Infringement by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] [Edit date 10/24/02] 6/14/02 203 **DUPLICATE COPY OF DECLARATION** (filed and docketed in error, original doc. #213) by Emily Evans University of Roch. in support of claim construction for US Patent No. 6,048,850 (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] [Edit date 10/18/02] 6/14/02 204 DECLARATION by Erica Wilson, attorney for University of Roch. in support of [196-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Infringement by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 205 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [204-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [203-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [202-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [201-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [200-1] support memorandum by University of Roch., [199-1] remark, [198-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [197-1] facts statement by University of Roch. upon all attorneys (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 207 CROSS MOTION by University of Roch. for Summary Judgment court to set return date (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 208 SEPERATE STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED FACTS by University of Roch. in support of plaintiff U of R's opposition to defendants' motion for summary judgment and plaintiffs [207-1] cross motion for Summary Judgment by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 209 DECLARATION by Erica Wilson in support of plaintiffs opposition to defendants motion for summary judgment and in support of University of Roch. Re: [207-1] cross motion for Summary Judgment by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 210 RESPONSE by University of Roch. in opposition to [170-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. and in support of cross motion for sum. jgm. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 211 DECLARATION by Dr. Edward Dennis, Professor at the University of California for University of Roch. Re: [207-1] cross motion for Summary Judgment by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 212 DECLARATION by Dr. John McGiff, Professor at NY Medical College for University of Roch. Re: [207-1] cross motion for Summary Judgment by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 213 DECLARATION by Emily Evans, attorney for University of Roch. Re: in support of Claim Construction for US Patnent No. 6,048,850 (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 214 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION by Erica Wilson, counsel for University of Roch. Re: [207-1] cross motion for Summary Judgment by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 215 Appendix of non-published authorities in support of plaintiff's opposition to defendants' motion for summary judgment and cross motion for summary judgment (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 216 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [215-1] remark, [214-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [213-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [212-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [211-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [210-1] opposition response by University of Roch., [209-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [208-1] facts statement by University of Roch. upon all attorneys (to) [Entry date 06/14/02] 6/14/02 217 ORDER, set Telephone Conference for 2:00 6/17/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 06/17/02] 6/17/02 228 Tele-conference held (WGB) (to) [Entry date 07/02/02] 6/24/02 221 ORDER granting [218-1] motion for David Lascell to Withdraw as Attorney (Terminated attorney David M. Lascell for University of Roch., attorney David M. Lascell for University of Roch., attorney David M. Lascell for University of Roch. ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to David M. Lascell, Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 06/24/02] 6/24/02 222 Stipulation and ORDER, defendants may file and serve their amended Pleadings within 10 days, and Response by plaintiff with 30 days after service, and plaintiffs motion challenging the Amended pleadings under FRCP 9 & 12 shall be heard according to a schedule adopted by the court, and the following page limits shall applyto plaintiffs motions: opening brief 25 pages; opposition 25 pages and reply 10 pages; parties may apply for leave if necessary ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 06/24/02] 6/27/02 223 Letter ORDER, granting Phizer's request to be permitted to file an oversized reply brief on its summary judgment motion ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 06/27/02] 6/28/02 224 AMENDED ANSWER and COUNTERCLAIM to Complaint by Pfizer Inc. : amends [5-1] answer by Pfizer Inc. (to) [Entry date 07/01/02] 6/28/02 225 REPLY MEMORANDUM by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. . [210-1] opposition response by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 07/01/02] 6/28/02 226 AMENDED ANSWER and COUNTERCLAIM to Complaint by G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. : amends [6-1] answer by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 07/01/02] 7/1/02 227 ORDER, set Telephone Conference for 2:00 7/1/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson, Carol E. Heckman (to) [Entry date 07/01/02] 7/1/02 229 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 07/03/02] 7/12/02 230 ORDER, set Telephone Conference for 2:00 7/15/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 07/12/02] 7/15/02 231 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 07/16/02] 7/16/02 232 LETTER by Paul Yesawich attorney for Phizer re: amended answer by def. Phizer which was missing pages 11 and 38 attached to this letter (to) [Entry date 07/17/02] 7/25/02 233 Letter ORDER, granting U of R leave to file a main brief of up to 35 pages in support of their motion to dismiss ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 07/25/02] 7/25/02 240 Minute entry: Oral argument; parties appear for argument; court reserves decision on the matter (DGL) (to) [Entry date 08/01/02] 7/25/02 241 Discovery/Status conference held (WGB) (to) [Entry date 08/01/02] 7/29/02 234 MOTION by University of Roch. to Strike, and/or to Dismiss defendants' inequitable conduct and unclean hands defenses and counterclaims, court to set return date (to) [Entry date 07/29/02] 7/29/02 235 Appendix of non-published authorities in support of plaintiff U of R's motion to strike or dismiss (to) [Entry date 07/29/02] 7/29/02 236 MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in support of [234-1] motion to Strike by University of Roch., [234-2] motion to Dismiss defendants' inequitable conduct and unclean hands defenses and counterclaims, court to set return date by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 07/29/02] 7/29/02 237 DECLARATION by Emily Evans attorney for University of Roch. Re: [234-1] motion to Strike by University of Roch., [234-2] motion to Dismiss defendants' inequitable conduct and unclean hands defenses and counterclaims, court to set return date by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 07/29/02] 7/29/02 238 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [237-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [236-1] support memorandum by University of Roch., [235-1] remark, [234-1] motion to Strike by University of Roch., [234-2] motion to Dismiss defendants' inequitable conduct and unclean hands defenses and counterclaims, court to set return date by University of Roch. served upon all counsel (to) [Entry date 07/29/02] 7/30/02 239 ORDER, Response to Motion set to 9/16/02 for [234-1] motion to Strike, set to 9/16/02 for [234-2] motion to Dismiss defendants' inequitable conduct and unclean hands defenses and counterclaims, court to set return date ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 07/31/02] 8/13/02 242 MOTION by University of Roch. for Win Hwangbo, Steven J. Koeninger, Kenneth Kuwayti, Cynthia Lopez, Marc Pernick, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Jennifer Piel, Cathryn Sadler, Bryan Ward and Rachel Williams to Appear Pro Hac Vice (to) [Entry date 08/14/02] 8/14/02 243 ORDER granting [242-1] motion for Win Hwangbo, Steven J. Koeninger, Kenneth Kuwayti, Cynthia Lopez, Marc Pernick, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Jennifer Piel, Cathryn Sadler, Bryan Ward and Rachel Williams to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 08/14/02] 8/14/02 -- PRO HAC VICE fee paid for all 10 attorneys. (to) [Entry date 08/14/02] 8/19/02 244 STIPULATION and ORDER, for Protective Order re: confidential information of non parties Merck & Co, Inc and Merck Frosst Canada & Co. signed by USMJ William G. Bauer . Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson . (jl) [Entry date 08/21/02] 8/26/02 245 ORDER, set Telephone Conference for 2:00 8/26/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 08/27/02] 8/26/02 246 Tele-conference held (WGB) (to) [Entry date 09/03/02] 9/5/02 247 TRANSCRIPT of proceedings before USDJ David Larimer, 7/25/02 at 9:30, pages 1-69 (to) [Entry date 09/05/02] 9/6/02 248 ORDER, set Telephone Conference for 2:00 9/9/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 09/09/02] 9/9/02 249 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 09/12/02] 9/13/02 250 MOTION by University of Roch., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. to Extend Time to respond, and an enlargement of the page limitation for the memo to 35 pages (to) [Entry date 09/13/02] 9/20/02 251 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (Defendants' memo in opp to plaintiff U of R motion to strike) (to) [Entry date 09/23/02] 9/20/02 252 DECLARATION by Colleen Tracy attorney for G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in supprot of sealed [251-1] document(s) (memo in opp to pl.'s motion) (to) [Entry date 09/23/02] 9/20/02 253 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. [252-1] affirmation by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co., [251-1] document(s) upon Erik Olson and Harold Kurland (to) [Entry date 09/23/02] 9/23/02 254 Letter ORDER, set Telephone Conference for 2:00 9/23/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 09/23/02] 9/23/02 255 SEALED MOTION by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. for sum jgm of patent invalidity for non enablement (to) [Entry date 09/24/02] 9/23/02 256 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault by defendants' (mem sup of motion #255) (to) [Entry date 09/24/02] 9/23/02 257 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault by defendants' (decl. by Colleen Tracy in sup of memo #256) (to) [Entry date 09/24/02] 9/23/02 258 STATEMENT OF FACTS by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. [255-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 09/24/02] 9/23/02 259 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION by Colleen Tracy, counsel to G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in further support of defendants' opposition to U of R's motion to strike or dismiss (to) [Entry date 09/24/02] 9/23/02 261 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 09/26/02] 9/24/02 260 LETTER by Michael Wolford attorney for defendants re: Memorandum of Law in support of defendants' opposition to plaintiff's motion to strike or dismiss (in the table of contents of the memo there is a misleading heading, therefore roman numeral IV should be roman numeral III and roman numeral V should be numeral IV) Also attached to this letter is a Table of Authorities which the Memo did not include (to) [Entry date 09/25/02] 9/25/02 262 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 09/27/02] 10/1/02 263 ORDER, set Status Conference for 2:00 10/7/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 10/01/02] 10/2/02 264 REPLY/RESPONSE by University of Roch. in support of [234-1] motion to Strike by University of Roch., [234-2] motion to Dismiss defendants' inequitable conduct and unclean hands defenses and counterclaims, court to set return date by University Roch. (to) [Entry date 10/02/02] 10/2/02 265 DECLARATION by Erica Wilson attorney for University of Roch. in support of [264-1] response reply by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 10/02/02] 10/2/02 266 Appendix of non published authorities in support of plaintiff's reply to motion to strike or dismiss (to) [Entry date 10/02/02] 10/2/02 267 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [266-1] remark, [265-1] affirmation by University of Roch., [264-1] response reply by University of Roch. upon all counsel (to) [Entry date 10/02/02] 10/4/02 268 ORDER, Response to Motion set to 11/8/02 for [255-1] motion SEALED MOTION, and Reply to Response to Motion set to 11/22/02 for [255-1] motion SEALED MOTION ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 10/04/02] 10/7/02 269 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 10/09/02] 10/18/02 270 ORDER, set Status Conference for 2:00 10/21/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 10/21/02] 10/21/02 272 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 10/24/02] 10/22/02 271 Letter ORDER, to Extend Time, and Response to Motion set to 12/2/02 for [255-1] motion SEALED MOTION motion for sum jgm by defendants ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 10/23/02] 10/23/02 273 STIPULATION PROTECTIVE ORDER with respect to confidential information of non-party Novartis; signed by USMJ William G. Bauer . Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson . (to) [Entry date 10/24/02] 10/24/02 274 Tele-conference held (WGB). (cm) [Entry date 10/25/02] 11/1/02 275 SEALED MOTION by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. (m. to compel) (to) [Entry date 11/04/02] 11/1/02 276 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (mem. sup. of m. #276) (to) [Entry date 11/04/02] 11/1/02 277 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. by Bruce Haas in support of motion #275) (to) [Entry date 11/04/02] 11/1/02 278 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. [277-1] document(s), [276-1] document(s), [275-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. upon plaintiff (to) [Entry date 11/04/02] 11/1/02 279 SEALED MOTION by Pfizer Inc. (m. for a protective o.) (to) [Entry date 11/04/02] 11/1/02 280 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. of Sylvia Becker in sup. of m. #279) (to) [Entry date 11/04/02] 11/1/02 281 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (mem. in sup. of m. #279) (to) [Entry date 11/04/02] 11/1/02 282 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. of Dr. Peter Corr in sup. of M. #279) (to) [Entry date 11/04/02] 11/5/02 -- Motion(s) referred: to Chief USDJ David G. Larimer : [250-1] motion to Extend Time to respond, [250-2] motion an enlargement of the page limitation for the memo to 35 pages (cm) [Entry date 11/05/02] 11/5/02 -- Deadline updated; terminating [182-1] motion for Leave to File Corrected Amended Answers and counterclaims pursuant to document #222. (cm) [Entry date 11/05/02] 11/5/02 -- Motion(s) referred: to Chief USDJ David G. Larimer : [255-1] motion SEALED MOTION, [250-1] motion to Extend Time to respond, [250-2] motion an enlargement of the page limitation for the memo to 35 pages, [167-1] motion to Compel the production of the invention disclosure underlying the patent in suit and certain testimony withheld based on improper assertions of privilege (cm) [Entry date 11/05/02] 11/6/02 -- Deadline updated; terminating [102-1] motion to Compel defendants GD Searle, Monsanto and Pharmacia to produce witnesses for deposition as moot. (cm) [Entry date 11/06/02] 11/7/02 283 MOTION by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. to Compel supplemental response to defendants' interrogatory no. 6 (to) [Entry date 11/08/02] 11/7/02 284 MEMORANDUM by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in support of [283-1] motion to Compel supplemental response to defendants' interrogatory no. 6 by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 11/08/02] 11/7/02 285 DECLARATION by Colleen Tracy attorney for G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. Re: [284-1] support memorandum by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 11/08/02] 11/7/02 286 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. [285-1] affirmation by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co., [284-1] support memorandum by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co., [283-1] motion to Compel supplemental response to defendants' interrogatory no. 6 by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. upon University of Rochester (to) [Entry date 11/08/02] 11/12/02 287 MEMORANDUM by University of Roch. in opposition to [279-1] motion SEALED MOTION (m. for proto.) by Pfizer Inc. (to) [Entry date 11/12/02] 11/12/02 288 DECLARATION by Erika Olson attorney for University of Roch. Re: [287-1] opposition memorandum by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/12/02] 11/13/02 289 MOTION by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. to Compel the U of R to produce re: Prosecution of Foreign Counterparts of the 850 Patent (to) [Entry date 11/13/02] 11/13/02 290 MEMORANDUM by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in support of [289-1] motion to Compel the U of R to produce re: Prosecution of Foreign Counterparts of the 850 Patent by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 11/13/02] 11/13/02 291 DECLARATION by Colleen Tracy, Esq. attorney for G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. Re: [289-1] motion to Compel the U of R to produce re: Prosecution of Foreign Counterparts of the 850 Patent by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 11/13/02] 11/14/02 292 SEALED MOTION to compel the U of R to produce a witness by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. (to) [Entry date 11/14/02] 11/14/02 293 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault mem. by def.'s in support of motion #292 (to) [Entry date 11/14/02] 11/14/02 294 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault decl. of Colleen Tracy (to) [Entry date 11/14/02] 11/14/02 295 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. [294-1] document(s), [293-1] document(s), [292-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 11/14/02] 11/15/02 296 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in support of motion for proto.) (to) [Entry date 11/18/02] 11/15/02 297 ORDER, sert Status Conference for 2:00 11/18/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 11/18/02] 11/15/02 298 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (rply. memo in sup. of its m. for a proto.) (to) [Entry date 11/18/02] 11/15/02 299 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of Phizers m. for a proto.) (to) [Entry date 11/18/02] 11/18/02 300 Letter ORDER, to Extend Time, Reply to Response to Motion set to 12/16/02 for [255-1] motion SEALED MOTION ( signed by USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 11/18/02] 11/18/02 301 MOTION by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. to Compel plaintiff to answer def.'s request for admissions court to set return date (to) [Entry date 11/18/02] 11/18/02 302 MEMORANDUM by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in support of [301-1] motion to Compel plaintiff to answer def.'s request for admissions by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 11/18/02] 11/18/02 303 DECLARATION by Coleen Tracy attorney for G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. Re: [301-1] motion to Compel plaintiff to answer def.'s request for admissions by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 11/18/02] 11/18/02 304 Tele-conference held (WGB) (cm) [Entry date 11/20/02] 11/19/02 305 ORDER, Motion Hearing set for 1:00 11/20/02 for [279-1] motion SEALED MOTION (m for proto.) ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 11/20/02] 11/20/02 335 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (Minutes) (to) [Entry date 12/03/02] 11/22/02 306 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (m. to compel unpriviledged docs by plaintiff) (to) [Entry date 11/22/02] 11/22/02 307 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (Pl. mem in sup. of m. #306) (to) [Entry date 11/22/02] 11/22/02 308 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of m. #306) (to) [Entry date 11/22/02] 11/22/02 309 SEALED CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [308-1] document(s), [307-1] document(s), [306-1] document(s) upon defendants (to) [Entry date 11/22/02] 11/25/02 310 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (transcript of proceeding 11/20/02) (to) [Entry date 11/26/02] 11/25/02 311 MOTION by University of Roch. to Compel unprivileged documents (to) [Entry date 11/26/02] 11/25/02 312 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault(mem. in sup.by pl. of m. #311) (to) [Entry date 11/26/02] 11/25/02 313 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of pl. m. #311) (to) [Entry date 11/26/02] 11/25/02 314 MOTION by University of Roch. for an order determining the sufficiency of defendants' responses to the U of R's requests for admission (to) [Entry date 11/26/02] 11/25/02 315 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (mem. by pl. re: m. #314) (to) [Entry date 11/26/02] 11/25/02 316 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. by pl. in sup. of m. #314) (to) [Entry date 11/26/02] 11/25/02 317 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [316-1] document(s), [315-1] document(s), [314-1] motion for an order determining the sufficiency of defendants' responses to the U of R's requests for admission by University of Roch., [313-1] document(s), [312-1] document(s), [311-1] motion to Compel unprivileged documents by University of Roch. upon defendants (to) [Entry date 11/26/02] 11/26/02 318 MOTION by University of Roch. to Compel production of witnesses (to) [Entry date 11/27/02] 11/26/02 319 DECLARATION by Erik Olson attorney for University of Roch. in support of [318-1] motion to Compel production of witnesses by University of Roch. (to) [Entry date 11/27/02] 11/26/02 320 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. by Lopez in sup. of m. #318) (to) [Entry date 11/27/02] 11/26/02 321 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (mem. in sup. of pl. m. #318) (to) [Entry date 11/27/02] 11/26/02 323 ORDER, set telephone Status Conference for 2:00 12/6/02 ( signed by USMJ William G. Bauer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 11/27/02] 11/27/02 322 Letter ORDER, granting the University leave to file a brief of up to 35 pages in opposition to defendant's motion for summary judgment ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 11/27/02] 12/2/02 324 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (pl. opp. to def.'s m.) (to) [Entry date 12/02/02] [Edit date 01/08/03] 12/2/02 -- Received Sealed Document by plaintiffs without original signiture (decl. of Schofield) waiting for original document (to) [Entry date 12/02/02] 12/2/02 325 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. by pl. in sup. of pl. opposition #324) (to) [Entry date 12/02/02] 12/2/02 326 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. by pl. in sup. of opp. by pl. #324) (to) [Entry date 12/02/02] 12/2/02 327 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of pl. opp. #324) (to) [Entry date 12/02/02] 12/2/02 328 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of pl. opp.#324) (to) [Entry date 12/02/02] 12/2/02 329 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of pl. opp. #324) (to) [Entry date 12/02/02] 12/2/02 330 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (Appendix) (to) [Entry date 12/02/02] 12/2/02 331 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (st. of facts) (to) [Entry date 12/02/02] 12/2/02 332 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by University of Roch. [331-1] document(s), [330-1] document(s), [329-1] document(s), [328-1] document(s), [327-1] document(s), [326-1] document(s), [325-1] document(s), [0-0] remark, [324-1] document(s) upon all counsel (to) [Entry date 12/02/02] 12/2/02 333 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of opp. by pl. #324) 3 volumes (to) [Entry date 12/02/02] 12/3/02 334 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of pl. opp. to def. motion) (to) [Entry date 12/03/02] 12/9/02 336 STIPULATION and PROTECTIVE ORDER with respect to confidential information of non party Glaxosmithkline, Inc. signed by USMJ William G. Bauer . Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson . (to) [Entry date 12/10/02] 12/16/02 337 MOTION by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. to Compel discovery (to) [Entry date 12/17/02] 12/16/02 338 MEMORANDUM by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in support of [337-1] motion to Compel discovery by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 12/17/02] 12/16/02 339 DECLARATION by Colleen Tracy attorney for G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in support of [337-1] motion to Compel discovery by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 12/17/02] 12/16/02 340 NOTICE of by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. of motion for an expidited briefing schedule (to) [Entry date 12/17/02] 12/16/02 341 MOTION by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. for an expidited briefing shcedule on defendants' motion to compel discovery court to set return date (to) [Entry date 12/17/02] 12/23/02 342 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (pl.'s mem opp to def.'s m to comp.) (to) [Entry date 12/23/02] 12/23/02 343 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (pl.'s mem opp to def.s m to compel) (to) [Entry date 12/23/02] 12/23/02 344 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (pl. memo in sup. of their opp.) (to) [Entry date 12/23/02] 12/23/02 345 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of pl.'s opp) (to) [Entry date 12/23/02] 12/23/02 346 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of pl.'s opp) (to) [Entry date 12/23/02] 12/23/02 347 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup of pl's opp) (to) [Entry date 12/23/02] 12/23/02 348 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of pl's opp) (to) [Entry date 12/23/02] 12/23/02 349 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (mem in sup of pl's opp) (to) [Entry date 12/23/02] 12/23/02 350 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (mem opp to def's m) (to) [Entry date 12/23/02] 12/23/02 351 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of pl's opp) (to) [Entry date 12/23/02] 1/10/03 352 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault; defendant's mem in opp to pl.'s motion for deter. of sufficiency) (to) [Entry date 01/10/03] 1/10/03 353 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup of opp. #352) (to) [Entry date 01/10/03] 1/10/03 354 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of opp. #352) (to) [Entry date 01/10/03] 1/10/03 355 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. by Pfizer in opp. to pl.'s m. to compel) (to) [Entry date 01/13/03] 1/10/03 356 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (mem. opp. to pl.'s m. to compel) (to) [Entry date 01/13/03] 1/10/03 357 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. in sup. of Pfizer's opp.) (to) [Entry date 01/13/03] 1/14/03 358 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (def.'s mem. in opp. to pl.'s m. to compel) (to) [Entry date 01/14/03] 1/14/03 359 DECLARATION by Michael Harte, attorney for G.D. Searle & Co., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. Re: [358-1] document(s) (to) [Entry date 01/14/03] 1/14/03 360 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. of J. Warner, Esq.) (to) [Entry date 01/14/03] 1/14/03 361 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. of Paul Rivard) (to) [Entry date 01/14/03] 1/14/03 362 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (decl. of Jonathan Muenkel, Esq) (to) [Entry date 01/14/03] 2/3/03 363 ORDER, Vacating [15-1] referral/referred order, and Referring Case to USMJ Jonathan W. Feldman ( signed by Chief USDJ David G. Larimer ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael Wolford, Robert L. Baechtold, Henry J. Renk, Nicholas M. Cannella, Paul J. Yesawich III, Charles W. Douglas, Richard F. O'Malley, David T. Pritikin, Richard G. Greco, Sylvia M. Becker, Gerald Sobel, Rachel Williams, Bryan Ward, Cathryn M. Sadler, Jennifer L. Piel, Kanika Radhakrishnan, Marc J. Pernick, Cynthia L. Lopez, Kenneth A. Kuwayti, Steven J. Koeninger, Win Hwangbo, Eric J. Ward, Harold A. Kurland, Erik Jefrey Olson, Emily A. Evans, Erica D. Wilson, Eric S. Walters, Gerald P. Dodson (to) [Entry date 02/05/03] 2/5/03 364 SECOND DECLARATION by Colleen Tracy, Esq. attorney for G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. Re: [289-1] motion to Compel the U of R to produce re: Prosecution of Foreign Counterparts of the 850 Patent by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 02/07/03] 2/5/03 365 REPLY MEMORANDUM by G.D. Searle & Co., Pfizer Inc., Monsanto Co., Pharmacia Corp. in support of [283-1] motion to Compel supplemental response to defendants' interrogatory no. 6 by Pharmacia Corp., Monsanto Co., Pfizer Inc., G.D. Searle & Co. (to) [Entry date 02/07/03] 2/5/03 366 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault (def.'s reply memo in sup. of def. m. to comp. 850 patent) (to) [Entry date 02/07/03] 2/11/03 367 SEALED